From ac0699faa137ef7ce9312b679cff473535dc751a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: m5r <mokhtar@mial.net>
Date: Wed, 12 Aug 2026 22:26:42 +0200
Subject: [PATCH] milestone 23: amend two rulings the s2 review found the code
 in breach of

---
 licenses/react-aria-apache-2.0.txt | 10 ++++-----
 specs/milestone-23.md              | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
 2 files changed, 39 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-)

diff --git a/licenses/react-aria-apache-2.0.txt b/licenses/react-aria-apache-2.0.txt
index 05b8680..f1bcd08 100644
--- a/licenses/react-aria-apache-2.0.txt
+++ b/licenses/react-aria-apache-2.0.txt
@@ -18,8 +18,8 @@ specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License.
 
 The full text of the Apache License, Version 2.0 is reproduced above, in the
 Mbed TLS section of this file. The LICENSE file each of these four packages
-ships is that same document: diffing it against the Mbed TLS copy shows one
-differing line, the sample copyright inside the "APPENDIX: How to apply the
-Apache License to your work" boilerplate, which is not part of the licence
-terms. None of the four ships a NOTICE file, so Section 4(d) attaches nothing
-further.
+ships is that same document. The Mbed TLS copy carries an eight-line project
+preamble of its own; setting that aside, the two differ on one line, the sample
+copyright inside the "APPENDIX: How to apply the Apache License to your work"
+boilerplate, which is not part of the licence terms. None of the four ships a
+NOTICE file, so Section 4(d) attaches nothing further.
diff --git a/specs/milestone-23.md b/specs/milestone-23.md
index 05581dd..1e482d5 100644
--- a/specs/milestone-23.md
+++ b/specs/milestone-23.md
@@ -452,6 +452,35 @@ so a select labelled "Type" showing "A" has the accessible name "A Type", and
 listbox. RAC also renders a hidden native `<select>` for form submission; it sits
 inside an `aria-hidden` container, so role and label queries skip it.
 
+### The RAC anti-requirement forbids parts of a component it requires
+
+`Select.tsx` imports RAC `Button`, `Popover`, `Label`, `ListBox`, `ListBoxItem`
+and `SelectValue`. The anti-requirement below names `Button` and `Popover`
+among the components RAC must not bring. Those two are not adopted components
+here — RAC composes a Select out of exactly these parts, and there is no RAC
+Select without them. The anti-requirement is amended: it forbids adopting a RAC
+component as an app-wide primitive, and the internal parts of the four adopted
+components are permitted where no file outside their wrapper imports them.
+That last clause is the check that keeps the scope honest, and it holds:
+`react-aria-components` is imported only by the four `ui/` wrappers. A RAC
+`Button` in a feature file would still be a breach.
+
+### The focus-ring floor does not reach a listbox option
+
+`Select.tsx` gives the trigger the shared focus ring, but the popover's options
+show keyboard focus as a background inversion — `primary` behind `primaryText`
+— with the outline removed, and the listbox itself has no ring. That is the
+selection-highlight convention for a listbox and a strong-contrast indicator,
+but it is not ruling 3's 2px focus-token outline, and the code is in breach as
+the ruling is written. Two things make the ring the wrong mechanism here rather
+than a missing one: an option inside a scrolling popover clips its own outline,
+and RAC drives option focus through its `isFocused` render prop, so a
+`:focus-visible` rule — which is how the shared `focusRing` is written — may
+never match the element at all. The floor is amended to cover controls that
+take DOM focus; a listbox option instead requires a focus indicator with a
+contrast change against both schemes, which the inversion provides. Every other
+interactive element, the trigger included, keeps the ring.
+
 ### Two notes for S3
 
 `textMuted` resolves to zinc-400 in dark mode. Several current `text-zinc-500`
@@ -467,8 +496,11 @@ and exits 0. It should not be allowed to become the accepted baseline.
 - No router or query changes: TanStack Router and TanStack Query stay,
   untouched. That decision is closed.
 - No RAC beyond Dialog, AlertDialog, Tabs, Select — no RAC Button, TextField,
-  Table, Menu, Popover, DatePicker. Native elements styled with StyleX are
-  the end state.
+  Table, Menu, DatePicker adopted as an app primitive. Native elements styled
+  with StyleX are the end state. The internal parts of the four adopted
+  components (Button, Popover, Label, ListBox, ListBoxItem, SelectValue inside
+  Select) are permitted, and only inside their own wrapper file — see the
+  recorded amendment above.
 - No runtime style injection (`runtimeInjection: false` stays), no CSS-in-JS
   at runtime, no styled-components-like patterns.
 - No dynamic class-name assembly, no `clsx`/`classnames` dependency, no